FANDOM


Commentaries that are widely held in high regard by viewers and commentators alike.

2013 Edit

Title Uploader Subject Released Length Praises Notes
Professor Commentaries - The Cloverfield Monster[1] TOGProfessor SaganFan1983 (back then known as TheOrionBroadcast) October 27, 2013 10:27
  • Sarcasm is used in an entertaining way.
  • Legitimate problems with the video pointed out.
  • Avatar: Franken Stein.
  • Second-degree commentary.
  • Commentated on by SaganFan1983.[2]

2014 Edit

Title Uploader Subject Released Length Praises Notes

2015 Edit

Title Uploader Subject Released Length Praises Notes
Lets Just Comment Episode 35 (Co-op): MDXLR - MDXLR is a Mall Cop[3] Mills Kohai Mistress Dove July 11, 2015 20:31
  • PLEASE FILL IN
  • Avatar: Sweetie Belle.
  • Quad-op with MasterTP10 (as Karl), MrSirRaven (Barry the Chopper) and Derterifii (Queen Chrysalis).
  • Cameos by ClayPot (as Ike and Guy Fieri), Scarlet Otaku (Black Rock Shooter), NESMario123 (Speakonia Joke Personas), and Hentie (xxx).
  • Second-degree commentary.
  • Intro by MrSirRaven.

2016 Edit

Title Uploader Subject Released Length Praises Notes
I Sereously Have A Bone 2 Pick[4] Doodletones SkeletonNation and SereousGamer33 April 15, 2016 17:11
  • PLEASE FILL IN
  • Avatars: Charmy Bee (SkeletonNation), and Tails (SereousGamer33).
  • Sixth-degree commentary (incorrectly labeled seventh in the video).
Lets Just Comment Episode 43: TheUtubedude101 - Jew Man Group Is Cancelled[5] Mills Kohai TheUtubedude101 April 22, 2016 22:17
  • PLEASE FILL IN
  • Avatar: It Me.
  • Third-degree commentary.
Hated Character Lists Are So 2010 (Commentary)[6] MasterTP10 Speedster May 27, 2016 52:23
  • PLEASE FILL IN
  • Avatar: Mimi Tachikawa (Digimon Adventure Tri).
  • Tri-op with DigitalTy (as Papyrus) and Alex Rochon (Mettaton EX).
  • Cameos by Kayden Marx (as his OC), Rabbidluigi (Arceus), Mills Kohai (It Me) and ItsMeAmphi (Voiceover).
Commentary: Cult of Dusty The Atheist Elitist[7] Blaze The Movie Fan Cult of Dusty October 22, 2016 18:00
  • Pointing out legitimate problems with Dusty's video.
  • People who normally don't like Blaze's commentaries admit he did a good job here.
  • Third-degree commentary.
  • Nine people reviewed the script. They are Emery Bowman, Kristal Colt, Danny Korcz, Mike's Island, GoldFinale, Doodletones, BurnCoalition and Lemminggaming.
Setting Fire to the Joshua Tree[8] Doodletones Various December 16, 2016 52:40
  • Called out everybody.
  • Pointed out how biased everyone was.
  • Made great counter-points.
  • Convinced everyone involved (except Obscurian) to cool down on videos on Joshua.
  • Tenth-degree commentary (calls out 16 degrees)
  • Avatar: Tomoko

2017 Edit

Title Uploader Subject Released Length Praises Notes
Commentary #25: Never Go Full Slothboy Part III[9] Dirtbikeredden and SkiHound Nihilistic Snake May 21, 2017 40:06
  • Good contrast in perspective compared to Redden and Ski's own commentary on SuperFunnyBros
  • Effectively calls out rampant plagiarism
  • Fifth-degree commentary
  • Ranked #2 on Akriloth2160's 10 Best Commentaries of 2017
  • Video was removed, but was re-uploaded by Slayer The Loli on July 28, 2018
Ponder Sprocket The Movie[10] Ponder Sprocket The Masked Starmaker, Illiniguy34, Chirprocks, The Illogical Reaper, Jorm, and MrAwesome 'N Mario360 July 2, 2017 2:09:13
  • Good points.
  • A video over an hour long done right.
A TP Carol MasterTP10, DigitalTy and BubblingBrooke MasterTP10 July 25, 2017 1:00:32
  • PLEASE FILL IN.
Digital Dissections: Ep. 2 - Lily Peet: A Digital Homocide Story[12] Aeron Tempest Lily Peet September 13, 2017 47:04
  • Backs up claims with verifiable evidence.
  • Legitimate points were being made throughout.
  • Very informative and entertaining.
  • Solid presentation.
Lets Just Comment Episode 51: C.A.N. - I Don't Wanna, The Movie

[15]

Mills Kohai Corporation of the Alternative Nitpickers (Jonah Smith, Darkcrimsonknight89, Supersonicward15, and Lunaticthegame) October 6, 2017 1:29:44
  • Fill in the blanks.
  • Avatar: Actual Me.
  • Edited by Doodletones.
  • Co-op with Doodletones (as Elizabeth), Gindemtaynayka (himself) and オタクがん (Julie).
  • Cameos by Post Rion (as Korekiyo Shinguji), Silver (The Devil via Dark Pit), Jiggy Shark (xxx), and Autumn Chan (her OC).
  • Second-degree commentary.
  • The long title of this commentary is "I Don't Wanna, The Movie Part IV: International C.A.N. of Mystery".

2018 Edit

Title Uploader Subject Released Length Praises Notes
Spoctor Theory! Gone Wrong! Gone Sm3xu4l![16] Ponder Sprocket Atari, Pentagrin, Stories, QuestionedTurkey, and qhostii April 25, 2018 1:50:06
  • Convincing everyone of the innocency of Spoctor (even Atari herself) and cleaning his reputation.
  • Showed that the subjects, who declared themselves victims of Spoctor Tech were either taking things out of context or not showing enough evidence to strengthen some of their claims.
  • Going out of her way to ask artists who collaborated with Spoctor to debunk the claims that he didn't pay them.
  • Avatar(s): Speed-painting and Ponder Sprocket (intro).
  • Edited by Doodletones.
  • Cameos by Autumn Chan (as voice-over of Atari), 8363MTR (as voice-over of Pentagrin), Slayer The Loli (as voice-over of Stories), Boonslayer (as voice-over of Spoctor and Toonslayer), Scarlet Otaku (as Lesbian [Ronni]), and Doodletones (as voice-over of Jettatura [Stories]).
  • Commentary on 5 videos.

Unknown release date Edit

Title Uploader Subject Released Length Praises Notes
Tubers93 is not funny BassClefEly (back then known as MSkull01) Tubers93 2011 Unknown
  • Legitimate points were being made throughout.
  • Even though the commentary itself is long gone, there does exist an edited version of it. Part 1 and 2

See also Edit

References Edit

  1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-N5cmNcYfro
  2. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qlKFifHFrd0
  3. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ASaSRxjlVqI
  4. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bfveEy5Nx4E
  5. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VD58e4jE7fM
  6. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H0yJdaLQuVw
  7. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sjwg8x9k0iQ
  8. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4vy0Uku2L7Y
  9. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zRncwuisZwI
  10. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lrucZ1027RA
  11. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vtTioCf-sx0
  12. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-QEDHvxBNQw
  13. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fwJOOCXuslc
  14. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vtTioCf-sx0
  15. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uNWOI2vt9DU
  16. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6pQrnhHFt8c